Florida Governor
The cancellation of the warrant was confirmed in a letter sent by the governor to the warden of the Florida State Prison in Raiford. Thompson had been sentenced to death for the 1976 murder of 23-year-old Sally Ivester, a case that has spanned nearly five decades of legal proceedings and multiple trials.
Legal Challenges and Medical Assessments
In the lead-up to the scheduled execution, Thompson’s attorneys filed an emergency petition with the Florida Supreme Court, arguing that their client’s physical and mental health had deteriorated to a point where he could no longer comprehend the nature of his punishment. Under state law, the governor appointed a panel of three psychiatrists to evaluate Thompson’s competency. While the results of the October 1 evaluation have not been publicly disclosed, the legal standard established by the U.S. Supreme Court prohibits the execution of individuals who lack a rational understanding of why they are being put to death.
Defense attorney Brittney Lacy described a client who appeared disoriented and unable to grasp basic information, including recent medical procedures. A neuropsychologist, Robert Ouaou, who examined Thompson, noted that the inmate appeared to be suffering from significant cognitive impairment and was often unable to identify current political figures or respond to basic verbal inquiries. Court documents further detailed reports from prison medical staff indicating that Thompson had become increasingly frail and disoriented, requiring emergency medical attention on several occasions.
Case Background and Procedural Status
The 1976 murder of Sally Ivester at a motel in North Miami Beach was described by authorities at the time as exceptionally brutal. Thompson and an accomplice, Rocco James Surace, were convicted for the killing, which involved prolonged physical abuse. Surace, who was also sentenced for his role in the crime, died in prison in 1993. Thompson’s legal journey included multiple trials and appeals over the decades, eventually leading to his return to death row in 1989.
Following the withdrawal of Thompson’s warrant, the state has moved forward with the execution of James Robertson, 63, who was sentenced to death for the 2008 murder of his cellmate. Robertson’s execution is currently scheduled for the same date previously set for Thompson. Grace Hanna, executive director of Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty, characterized the governor’s decision to halt Thompson’s execution as the correct course of action, citing his severe illness and intellectual disability as factors that would have rendered the execution a violation of the Eighth Amendment.